Thursday, August 7, 2008

ANIME REVIEW - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya






Like most teens, high school freshman Kyon is trying to make peace with what he believes is a profoundly dull existence. When his attractive but eccentric classmate Haruhi announces to their class that she “only wants to meet espers (psychics), aliens, and future men”, Kyon’s teasing convinces the strong-willed and haughty Haruhi to form her own club devoted to finding the afore-mentioned psychics, aliens, and time travelers – and Kyon is to be her first member, willing or not! Haruhi’s forcefulness soon finds the pair an unused club room, and Haruhi soon recruits/strong-arms 3 other classmates into joining the “SOS Brigade”: the quiet, bookish Yuki, handsome and easy going Koizumi, and the sweet but timid Mikuru. Despite Haruhi’s demanding personality, all seems fine…until the 3 new members privately reveal to Kyon that they are, in fact, either an alien (Yuki), a psychic (Koizumi), or a time traveler (Mikaru). Furthermore, they have all been sent to monitor Haruhi – who they believe has the unconscious ability to alter reality and the fabric of time and space itself! The only way to prevent serious damage to the universe is to keep Haruhi entertained and to go along with her whims…but can the cynical Kyon keep up the façade?

***

Judging from the both the number of Haruhi Suzumiya cosplayers and MoHS-related merchandise I’ve seen, I was well aware of the MoHS phenomena going in; and when Koizumi, Yuki, and Mikaru each revealed the nature of Haruhi’s powers, I began to look forward to the idea that the series was going to a weird philosophical turn. Unfortunately, this plot element is never really resolved; it’s left as a red herring, and is only occasionally referenced later. And what does happen in the series is, well, a little lame: Haruhi cons a computer off the school computer club! Haruhi solves a (fake) murder! Haruhi makes the club join a baseball tournament! Haruhi dresses in a bunny-girl costume and plays rock n’ roll at the school fair! Golly!

This is all entertaining and charming, but its rote - nothing that hasn’t been done in any number of high-school comedy anime series. MoHS definitely has flash, great art, and likeable characters, but there’s just not a lot of substance – at least, not enough to deserve all the hype it’s gotten. The interesting ideas and plot twists you encounter early on don’t amount to anything; it’s as if the original scriptwriters quit in the middle of the series and were replaced by “high school high-jinks” hacks.

Still, this series has one highly redeeming quality: Haruhi. The fact that she’s actually a strong, attractive, assertive, and smart female lead character that isn’t stuck doing panty-shots the whole series is a refreshing change; I can understand why so many female anime fans are fond of her. I wouldn’t call this a feminist anime (Haruhi’s “forced cosplay” with Mikaru borders on molestation), but the sex jokes are practically non-existent, the female characters are multi-dimensional and not treated like objects, and the male characters (well, Kyon and Koizumi) are thoughtful, sensitive, and obliging; even the cheesecake shots of Yuki, Mikaru, and Haruhi are tastefully done.

To sum it up, MoHS is a big letdown in terms of plot, but enjoyable if you just focus on the characters. I still think there are far better series out there under the radar (cough cough Welcome to the NHK cough Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei cough cough) but MoHS has a charm all it’s own.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Manga Review – Pumpkin Scissors Vo1 1 and 2 by Iwanaga Ryotaro


Although the terrible war between the Empire and the Republic of Frost has ended, the war’s horrors remain – destruction, disease, hunger, crime, and corruption. In an attempt to try and remedy some of the situation, the Imperial Army has created State Section III (aka “Pumpkin Scissors” for its ability to “snip” through the thick “pumpkin shell” of corruption and desperation) to combat banditry and aid in the relief and reconstruction of the Empire. But with little respect and even less funding, Pumpkin Scissors - and it’s proud but strident field commander 2nd Lt Alice L. Malvin – have their hands full combating the crime and deprivation that plagues the Imperial countryside. When the platoon receives assistance from a kindly but mysterious ex-solider named Randel Orland, they’re shocked to find out that the “gentle giant” they befriended is actually a former member of a secret tank-killing brigade - and a deadly and unstoppable killing machine in his own right. With Randel at their side, Pumpkin Scissors must confront angry civilians, bent politicians, and thuggish ex-soldiers, and a secret and bloodthirsty military organization known only as the “Invisible 9” - who may hold the key to Randel’s mysterious past….

Similar to the classic Patlabor series in it’s “bad division” formula (i.e. a misunderstood and unpopular brigade of talented eccentrics use their skill and bravery to slowly win the respect and admiration of friend and foe alike), PS wins points for it’s setting and characterizations; Iwanaga creatively choose to set the series in a fictional version of 1930’s Europe (albeit with slight Japanese social overtones), with the resulting technology of the day – without wireless radios, jets, or submachine guns, the action is a gritty mix of tanks, rifles, and sheer guts. Iwanaga also uses humor to good degree; with the exception of Randel, the personal of Pumpkin Scissors are obviously pencil-pushers unsuited to the stress of actual combat. The art is a little rough at first but soon improves to a style that’s both cartoonish and sharp, and the action scenes are exciting and well-rendered.

All in all, Pumpkin Scissors is a well-done and straightforward action series with elements of humor and political intrigue; I look forward to subsequent volumes.

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Manga Review - A.I. Love You – Vol 1 by Ken Akumatsu



Ken Akumatsu is known primarily through his seminal harem comedy Love Hina (hey, another Love Hina ref on this blog! What does that make, #476?) and his newer magical action/fan-service extravaganza Negima! Master Negi Magi…but before he truly began to master the art of panty-shots, he wrote this series. And wow, what a difference 5 years makes in terms of a mangaka’s abilities.

Computer nerd Hitoshi gets absolutely zero female attention – with the exception of No. 30, the kind and caring life-like Artificial Intelligence program he’s created on his computer. When a freak electrical storm turns No. 30 into a real girl, Hitoshi must juggle their nascent relationship with her weird powers and origin….

Yeah yeah yeah, we’ve heard all it before!

Now, I dig rote manga storytelling as much as the next dork, but I’ll be damned if this isn’t a dull retread of Ah! My Goddess (mixed with a little of Weird Science). Shall we count the similarities?


1. Hero is physically unimpressive, has few talents (aside from some technical skills), and is unpopular with the ladies.
2. Despite being somewhat naïve, the Heroine is caring, giving, beautiful, and utterly devoted to the Hero.
3. Heroine can communicate with and control electrical/mechanical devices.
4. Heroine has two female “siblings” that appear later in the series – a sexy older one and a precocious younger one.
5. Artwork goes from awful to awesome over the course of the series.
6. Characters all attend Nekomi Institute of Technology (joke).

From what I’ve seen of A.I. Love You (which I grant is only Vol. 1), its best left to Akumatsu nuts or people who love the Ah! My Goddess “magical girlfriend” formula so much that they’re willing to read a sub-standard copy.

Still, we all have to start somewhere, and a talented mangaka like Akumatsu can be forgiven for crude artwork and a derivative storylines in their early work – part of the joy of manga (and graphic novels in general) is seeing the creators grow and mature over time.

Tuesday, June 24, 2008

anime/manga review: Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei


My School Comedy jones continues unabated, so today I’ll be taking a look at a new favorite – Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (or in English, “Goodbye, Prof. Despair”), which attempts to answer the immortal question: what happens when the world’s most negative man meets the world’s most positive girl?

Moody and melancholy high school teacher Nozuma has decided to end it all by hanging himself in a grove of cherry trees….only to find out that his suicide attempt has been by Kafuka, an insanely optimistic school girl who can’t believe he’s attempting suicide on such a wonderful spring day - and in front of her favorite cherry trees to boot!

Rather than be subjected to her positivistic prattle, the wane young man bolts, and Kafuka continues on to school….where her new homeroom teacher is none other than, yes, Nozuma. To make matters worse, Nozomu realizes that the uber-optimistic Kafuka is the least of his problems - every student in class appears to be total head cases, rivaling their new teacher in neurosis. It’s up to Nozomu to help his student resolve their issues….and serve up a heaping dose of negativity to boot.

SZS is one of those cases where “the whole is more than the sum of its parts” – the theme of “eccentric teacher helping his eccentric students work through their problems” is a withered old chestnut that’s been used by everyone from Great Teacher Onizuka to Welcome Back, Kotter. But creator Koji Kumeta takes this standard school comedy formula and twists it into something utterly unique, mixing blacker-than-black comedy along with offbeat wordplay and pop-culture in-jokes, all done in a refreshingly gothic/minimalist art style – imagine a manga Edward Gorey and you’re almost there.

Visually, this is one of the most striking and original series I’ve watched/read lately, with simple, almost Osamu Tezuka-influenced character designs, eerie gothic flourishes, and a black/white contrast that rivals even Jamie Hernandez (Love and Rockets). Kumeta ups the weirdness quotient by adding vaguely out-of-date clothing, TVs, and buildings, despite the clear inference that the series is set in the present day.

Although most of SZS’s offbeat and dark humor can be easily understood by most readers, I fear that some folks many be put off by how Japan-specific some of the jokes are – like Yakitate Japan, the puns and wordplay comes fast and thick, and the references to Japanese culture (both high and pop) make leave some readers scratching their heads. However, ambitious readers will be rewarded with a bleakly hilarious take on “modern Japanese visual culture”.

It also bears mention that this is the first series that I’ve read/watched that was entirely online – no DVDs or print manga have appeared in the USA as of yet (Del Ray is planning to release the English-language version of the manga sometime in 2009); in the meantime, you can check out fan-subbed versions here:

http://www.sidereel.com/Sayonara_Zetsubo_Sensei
http://www.onemanga.com/Sayonara_Zetsubou_Sensei/

Thursday, June 5, 2008

ANIME REVIEWS – Kujibiki Unbalance and Doki Doki School Hours

In the course of this blog, I’ve touched on a few different genres in anime/manga – Best in Japan (see Yakitate Japan), magical girlfriend (Oh My Goddess!, DearS), harem comedy (Love Hina), space opera/big robots (Gundam ad infinitum), etc. – and today I’ll like to talk about Kujibiki Unbalance and Doki Doki School Hours, two example of School Comedy, a genre that I’ve been increasingly interested in. Like Great Teacher Onizuka, Negima, Azumanga Diaoh, Full Metal Panic! FFUMOFU and School Rumble, Kujibiki Unbalance and Doki Doki School Hours are set in a place where many of us had to spend way more time than we wanted: high school.






Kujibiki Unbalance has a typical set up - hard luck guy Chihiro and perky tomboy Tokino are childhood friends who’ve just entered the prestigious Rikkyouin Academy. On the first day of school, all students are required to draw lottery tickets (kujibiki) – and Chihiro and Tokino find that they’ve won the job of President and Vice-President of next year’s student council! Along with Secretary and Treasurer-to-be (the crabby, undersized mad scientist Renko, and shy grade-schooler Kyoyi, respectively) next year’s student council must fulfill increasingly outlandish tasks by the order of the current student council (under the command of the mysterious and icily beautiful half-German/half-Japanese Ritsuko Kubel Kitterand)….and if Chihiro, Tokino, Rendo, and Kyoki fail at even one, they may find themselves expelled!

Although appealing in its own way, with occasional flashes of screwball humor, KU remains a very average series; ironically so, because it was meant to be a parody of/homage to contemporary anime trends. KU is actually a spin-off of Genshikan (a “slice of life” manga/anime about a college anime club) and KU was the “series within a series” that the members of the club watched obsessively - so it’s “averageness” seems like a clever design element. That’s not to say that there aren’t uniquely…disturbing elements to the series; despite the fact it’s played for laughs, even for a seasoned fan like myself found the incestuous attachment Chihiro’s older sister has for him to be more than little unsettling.

Visually, it’s definitely moe, resembling Ken Akamatsu’s Negima to a great degree (presumably intentional) and its theme – romantic situations resulting from childhood promises, madcap humor and bizarre plot turns – are typical of Akamatsu’s work as well.

----







Just as KU is heavily influenced by Negima and Love Hina, Doki Doki School Hours draws a perceivable influence from Azumanga Diaoh – even sharing origins as a 4-panal manga. Like AD, it centers around the daily interactions of an eccentric high school teacher (the baby-faced and somewhat immature Mika Suzuki, aka “Mika-sensei) and her equally eccentric students – the sarcastic Tominaga, ditzy Kobeyashi, goody-two shoes Iinchou (the girls); and dumb jock Suetake, prettyboy narcissist Seki, nerdy otaku Watabe, and stoic Nakamura (the boys).

Pretty standard stuff, but what I found extremely unique about this series was the inclusion of two clearly homosexual characters into the class: the lesbian Kitagawa and male homosexual Kudo. Neither character is treated as being anything other than normal, and aside from their occasional inappropriate methods of expressing their desires (Kudo’s romantic fantasies of dumb jock Suetake result in constant nosebleeds, and Kitagawa can’t keep her hands off Mika-sensei), neither character is treated as anything outside of the norm. Even at this point it’s still relatively uncommon to see an openly gay character on conservative American TV, so seeing openly gay teens in an anime is surprising - and refreshing.

Another interesting element of DDSH is the fact that Mika-sensei is a “parasite single”, an unmarried adult living at home with her parents even though she’s in her late 20s – an increasingly common situation in modern Japan. Despite the protests of her snarky mother, Mika-sensei’s soft-hearted dad continues to spoil her by feeding, clothing, and even driving the pathetic Mika-sensei to work in his car. Although with the homosexual characters, this plot element helps to ground the series in day-to-day reality; in fact, I wish more anime and manga were willing to incorporate elements of the “everyday” rather than rely so heavily on their trademarked escapism.

Wednesday, May 21, 2008

King City, Vol. 1 - Brandon Graham




The OEL trend continues with this work by American mangaka/cartoonist Brandon Graham.

Recently returned to sprawling and surrealistic King City from secret spy training in the mountains, sullen loner and “angry young man” Joe is taking on any spy or theft-related job he can find. Armed with a mutant cat that can transform into a living weapon or tool with a simple injection, Joe bumbles onto a conspiracy when he finds the mysterious buyer of a key that he’s stolen dead on the street. When the dead man’s femme fatal of a girlfriend hires him to spy on a weird cannibal cult, Joe realizes that the stolen key leads to something weirder and more horrific than he can imagine….

Although King City shows a definite manga influence, it’s clear that the druggy and dreamlike work of American and European cartoonists (Moebius in particular) pervades King City. Likewise, the plot has little in common with traditional manga-style storytelling, instead drawing heavily on the uniquely American hard-boiled style of Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammett (both of whom happen to be favorites of mine) along with a healthy dose of science fiction. Although a few of the jokes fall flat and the dialog is a little gimmicky at times, Graham brings a uniquely hip-hop and pop-culture influenced worldview to his work that is quite unlike any American or Japanese work currently out there – I look forward to seeing Volume 2.

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Ah! My Goddess!/Oh My Goddess! by Kosuke Fujishima


When a misplaced phone call connects him to the Realm of the Gods, good-hearted but unlucky college student Keiichi inadvertently finds himself the recipient of a wish…and a beautiful goddess named Belldandy is to be the one to fulfill it. When Keiichi’s wish – “to stay with you forever” – is granted, he now has to deal with a goddess (and her two outlandish sisters) living with him!

One of the most popular series outside of Japan, there have been 4 versions of the A! MG! anime (not counting full-length movies and spin-off series). I first saw the original A!MG! anime series back in 1997 as a fan-sub, and it was even old then; it’s been published in manga form since 1989 and shows no sigh of stopping. A! MG! holds a particular place in my heart, as this was the series that introduced me to “real” (i.e. subtitled) anime back in the mid-90s; not only was it the first “fansubbed” series I saw, but it was also one of the first subtitled animation I’d been exposed to as well. I know a lot of you younger folks got your exposure to Naruto, Bleech, etc, via cable, but fan-sub anime was a rare find back in those pre-BitTorrent days.

In terms of storyline, the length of A! MG! precludes a detailed plot overview. There was a certain slap-sticky element to the early stories, as Keiichi was forced to cover up the fact that his new girlfriend was actually a powerful and magical being, while trying to maintain a normal life; once Urd and Skuld entered the series, their mischief and ham-fisted attempts at living like mortals began to drove the plot, along with introduction of more “mystical” elements and action. Due to the fact that both Keiichi and Belldandy are excellent motorcycle riders and mechanics, there has been a large emphasis on racing action during the course of the series as well (which Fujishima excels in depicting).

So, does it hold up after all these years? Well, yes and no. Along with Ureisei Yatsura, this series really popularized the “magical girlfriend” genre that’s been used countless times…so in a sense, the blame for the glut of bland/borderline sexist “magical girlfriend” can be laid at A!MG!’s feet. I’m sure I’m not alone in my perception of series heroine Belldandy as being a little too “perfect”– more often than not, she seems to have little personality and little motivation beyond being nice to Keiichi. However, you’re always stuck dealing with the fact that there’s a certain amount of fan-boy wish fulfillment in any shonen manga series (hell, most manga or comics are basically wish-fulfillment anyway) – and A!MG! is very mild compared to some of the more modern series.

With excellent art* and amazingly detailed mechanical rendering of the many motorbikes and machines that appear in the series, A! MG! remains a charming, good-natured work, (even after 19 years) probably due to the fact that it has a uniquely easy-going feel that’s easy to like and welcoming to non-manga readers. Along with Akira, Neon Genesis Evangelion, and any Rumiko Takahashi series, this is one of those anime/manga works that every self-respecting otaku has been exposed to at least once.

*- (presently, at least - the early art is amazingly dated and “80’s” looking. Fans of 1980’s Masamune Shirow series ala New Dominion Tank Police and Appleseed will know what I mean…)