Kekkaishi is prime example of the current shonen style of manga: an excitable, impetuous young hero who’s enormously talented (but stubborn and sort of lazy) has to hunt down rouge spirits and angry demons with the help of a loyal but wise-cracking sidekick; some readers out there will probably recognize this as being the exact plot as Bleach. The “excitable but lazy young guy” has long been a stock manga hero, but “demon-hunting” heroes seem to be especially popular these days; in fact, I’d say it’s replaced the Dragonball Z-style “ultimate fighter”/brawl as the shonen formula de jour (The “supernatural” has long had long been a popular topic in Japanese culture, and an astute anime/manga buff can observe it has provided the base of a wide range of current manga and anime – see XXXholic, Princess Resurrection, Hell Girl, Vampire Rosario, etc).
Still, formulaic as Kekkaishi is, there are some redeeming qualities. The occasional use of traditional Japanese ukiyo-e “ghost pictures” is a nice contrast to the sturdy, simple artwork that makes up most of the manga. The clan rivalry between Yoshimori’s and Tokine’s families harks back to old samurai traditions, but it’s cleverly played for humor: the “rival clans” act more like argumentative neighbors fighting over lawn clippings rather than inheritors of a proud warrior culture.
Although it’s not breaking any new ground, Kekkaishi at least succeeds in being a straight-forward and accessible take on the current shonen formula; older readers will have probably seen it all before, but younger ones will eat it up.
____
With a tight, plot-driven structure, Othello lacks the complex social/romantic structure of many shojo manga, and focuses more on purely Japanese growing pains – bullying, Loligoth cosplay, J-Rock, and a still-traditional relation between the sexes. The artwork also tends toward realism, i.e. no over the top bishonen/bishojo, chibi sidekicks, or overly cutesy characters. Both of these factors will make Othello attractive to older or occasional manga readers – guys too.