Thursday, July 17, 2008

Manga Review – Pumpkin Scissors Vo1 1 and 2 by Iwanaga Ryotaro


Although the terrible war between the Empire and the Republic of Frost has ended, the war’s horrors remain – destruction, disease, hunger, crime, and corruption. In an attempt to try and remedy some of the situation, the Imperial Army has created State Section III (aka “Pumpkin Scissors” for its ability to “snip” through the thick “pumpkin shell” of corruption and desperation) to combat banditry and aid in the relief and reconstruction of the Empire. But with little respect and even less funding, Pumpkin Scissors - and it’s proud but strident field commander 2nd Lt Alice L. Malvin – have their hands full combating the crime and deprivation that plagues the Imperial countryside. When the platoon receives assistance from a kindly but mysterious ex-solider named Randel Orland, they’re shocked to find out that the “gentle giant” they befriended is actually a former member of a secret tank-killing brigade - and a deadly and unstoppable killing machine in his own right. With Randel at their side, Pumpkin Scissors must confront angry civilians, bent politicians, and thuggish ex-soldiers, and a secret and bloodthirsty military organization known only as the “Invisible 9” - who may hold the key to Randel’s mysterious past….

Similar to the classic Patlabor series in it’s “bad division” formula (i.e. a misunderstood and unpopular brigade of talented eccentrics use their skill and bravery to slowly win the respect and admiration of friend and foe alike), PS wins points for it’s setting and characterizations; Iwanaga creatively choose to set the series in a fictional version of 1930’s Europe (albeit with slight Japanese social overtones), with the resulting technology of the day – without wireless radios, jets, or submachine guns, the action is a gritty mix of tanks, rifles, and sheer guts. Iwanaga also uses humor to good degree; with the exception of Randel, the personal of Pumpkin Scissors are obviously pencil-pushers unsuited to the stress of actual combat. The art is a little rough at first but soon improves to a style that’s both cartoonish and sharp, and the action scenes are exciting and well-rendered.

All in all, Pumpkin Scissors is a well-done and straightforward action series with elements of humor and political intrigue; I look forward to subsequent volumes.

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Manga Review - A.I. Love You – Vol 1 by Ken Akumatsu



Ken Akumatsu is known primarily through his seminal harem comedy Love Hina (hey, another Love Hina ref on this blog! What does that make, #476?) and his newer magical action/fan-service extravaganza Negima! Master Negi Magi…but before he truly began to master the art of panty-shots, he wrote this series. And wow, what a difference 5 years makes in terms of a mangaka’s abilities.

Computer nerd Hitoshi gets absolutely zero female attention – with the exception of No. 30, the kind and caring life-like Artificial Intelligence program he’s created on his computer. When a freak electrical storm turns No. 30 into a real girl, Hitoshi must juggle their nascent relationship with her weird powers and origin….

Yeah yeah yeah, we’ve heard all it before!

Now, I dig rote manga storytelling as much as the next dork, but I’ll be damned if this isn’t a dull retread of Ah! My Goddess (mixed with a little of Weird Science). Shall we count the similarities?


1. Hero is physically unimpressive, has few talents (aside from some technical skills), and is unpopular with the ladies.
2. Despite being somewhat naïve, the Heroine is caring, giving, beautiful, and utterly devoted to the Hero.
3. Heroine can communicate with and control electrical/mechanical devices.
4. Heroine has two female “siblings” that appear later in the series – a sexy older one and a precocious younger one.
5. Artwork goes from awful to awesome over the course of the series.
6. Characters all attend Nekomi Institute of Technology (joke).

From what I’ve seen of A.I. Love You (which I grant is only Vol. 1), its best left to Akumatsu nuts or people who love the Ah! My Goddess “magical girlfriend” formula so much that they’re willing to read a sub-standard copy.

Still, we all have to start somewhere, and a talented mangaka like Akumatsu can be forgiven for crude artwork and a derivative storylines in their early work – part of the joy of manga (and graphic novels in general) is seeing the creators grow and mature over time.